Switch to Washi Tape
Regular scotch tape is made with plastic and is non recyclable. Washi tape, on the other hand, is made with natural fibres, like hemp or bamboo, is biodegradable and serves the same purpose. It is very durable and comes in all sorts of different colours and designs as well. Avoid the designs that incorporate metallic paint, plastic or glitter and instead chose the simple paper ones. You can also ask the seller what types of dyes are used to create the different colours if you really want to cover your bases.